Balloon Debate: what’s the best invention ever? I proposed language & debated other ideas. View this ‘Battle of Ideas’ festival film.
Filmed at the Battle of Ideas and expertly chaired by Timandra Harkness, this incredibly engaging balloon debate sees panelists attempt to convince the audience of their choice for the best invention ever. At the end of each round, the least popular invention is eliminated – and its proponent thrown out of the balloon. The debate gets to grips with what makes a good invention too. Should we laud those who came up with something first, those who perfected it or those who made it popular? Do we celebrate the collective effort of inventions developed over centuries or the individual genius who dreamed it to life? And the very deserving winner is…..watch it and see by clicking on this Worldbytes link:
The film is also available to view on You Tube if you click on this link:
Balloon debate: what’s the best invention ever?
Saturday 17 October, 2015, 17.30 until 18.45, Frobisher 4-6, Barbican The New Industrial Revolution?
US economist Robert Gordon provoked debate last year when he claimed that invention was largely over, arguing that ‘all the important stuff’ had already been invented. This seemed to fly in the face of the regular announcement of revolutionary new technologies: from driverless cars and robot butlers through to multi-billion dollar apps and smart fridges. Yet a surprising number of voices echoed Gordon’s comments: after the rapid advancement of the twentieth century, when mankind went from first flight to moon landing in a few decades, the twenty-first century has seen lots of hype – and the occasional iPhone upgrade. Some have dubbed this era the Great Stagnation, where innovation has been reduced to tinkering around in the margins.
The debate raises an important question: what is the hallmark of a truly great invention? Leonardo is said to have ‘invented’ the helicopter, but you’d rather take a trip in Sikorsky’s models. The Pill was stumbled upon – as Carl Djerassi freely admitted – largely by accident. Some inventions are doomed to obsolescence or become victims of their own success: the age of penicillin is seemingly now giving way to the age of antibiotic resistance. At the same time, far more of us could name the inventor of the telephone than the mobile (Martin Cooper). Meanwhile, this year’s anniversary of the dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki is a sobering reminder that not all great inventions have noble aims. Some say that the truly great inventions are intangible – literary critic Harold Bloom once claimed that Shakespeare ‘invented’ humanity – but patent offices tend not to agree.
Is an invention’s greatness a simple numbers game – lives saved or improved – or is it about how it transformed our knowledge of what is possible? In the age of nanotechnology, does size still matter? Should we laud those who came up with something first, those who perfected it or those who made it popular? Do we celebrate the collective effort of inventions developed over centuries or the individual genius who dreamed it to life? Join us for this balloon debate as we ask – what is the greatest invention?
co-publisher, Machine Books
project administrator, Physics Factory
founding director, Copper Clothing
Dr Dominic Standish
author, ‘Venice in Environmental Peril? Myth and Reality’; lecturer, University of Iowa’s CIMBA campus, Venice region, Italy
science and health communicator
writer, editor and adviser on environmental solutions and sustainable futures; chair, editorial board http://www.collectively.org; launch director, Forum for the Future (India)
journalist, writer & broadcaster; presenter, Futureproofing and other BBC Radio 4 programmes; author, ‘Big Data: does size matter?’
David Bowden associate fellow, Institute of Ideas; culture writer